How did NCIP start?

Co-founders Kathleen “Cookie” Ridolfi and Linda Starr had both already worked for years in criminal justice in a variety of settings, including as trial and appellate lawyers, when they took on the cases that would become NCIP’s earliest exonerations. With volunteer staff and law students from an existing criminal law clinic, they launched NCIP officially in 2001, in part to respond to the passage of California Penal Code section 1405, which for the first time authorized convicted inmates to seek DNA testing to prove their innocence. That statute provided a vehicle to discover the existence of previously undetected wrongful convictions, and raised the probability of successful post-conviction litigation.

How many inquiries do you get per year?

NCIP receives approximately 2,500 letters each year from inmates and family members about new or existing cases. Approximately 750 of those are new requests for assistance. NCIP reads and responds to every letter it receives.

How do you decide which cases to take?

We have a rigorous case screening process to determine which cases we take. The process starts when we receive a letter asking for help. We receive nearly 2000 such letters each year. We respond to each letter and, for new cases, we send our intake questionnaire to the inmate, which allows him or her to provide us with key information about their case. Our staff reviews the completed questionnaires and, where appropriate, obtains additional documentation about the conviction. We may review police reports (where these are available), transcripts and prior legal briefing. At that point, cases that continue to hold promise are assigned to an NCIP staff attorney for more thorough investigation. That investigation may include some or all of the following: interviewing witnesses who have new information; locating physical evidence for forensic or DNA testing; and consulting with experts about potential errors in forensic, medical, or police practices that may have contributed to a wrongful conviction. If we find compelling evidence of factual innocence, we share our findings and attempt to resolve the case through discussion with prosecutors (the best case scenario). Sometimes, however, we need to initiate litigation to overturn the conviction. We currently have more than 60 active cases pending.

How do you know that a person is innocent?

Where we believe there may be a case of innocence, we investigate thoroughly. The nature of the investigation is determined by the specific evidence in the case. In every case the evidence is different. Some cases are driven by witness statements, while others are largely based on forensic evidence. The investigative process is meticulous and can take a long time. Of the many cases which come into our pipeline, we only proceed to litigation in the few cases in which the investigation discloses compelling evidence of actual innocence.

Will NCIP take my case?

In order to have your case considered by NCIP, you must meet all of the following criteria: 1) you must be actually innocent of the crimes for which you have been convicted; 2) There must be a significant chance that substantial new evidence may be found to support your claim of innocence; 3) you must have been convicted in a Central or Northern California state court of a serious felony; 4) you must currently be incarcerated. To see more about how to apply for help and more details about NCIP’s case eligibility criteria click here.

What is your relationship to The Innocence Project (New York)?

People often get us confused. The Innocence Project in New York is one of a network of Innocence Projects throughout the US and abroad working to exonerate innocent people. It was the first Innocence Project in the US and is the largest, often working on national level initiatives. NCIP is the second largest project in the US. NCIP and The Innocence Project are independent organizations but we are both active members of the Innocence Network. We are colleagues who share information and refer cases to one another where appropriate. NCIP also frequently works with the Innocence Project on policy issues, such as supporting California or federal legislative efforts.

What is your relationship to Santa Clara University School of Law?

NCIP is a project of the Santa Clara University School of Law. NCIP staff are employees of the law school, however NCIP raises its own funds and administers its own budget. Several NCIP staff hold faculty appointments at SCU Law. The NCIP law clinic is run by NCIP and is a year-long course offered by SCU Law. In addition to our clinical students, we also employ a small number of law students as Research Assistants. SCU undergraduates with an interest in the law often serve as volunteer interns at NCIP.

What is your relationship to the Innocence Network?

NCIP was one of the founding members of the Innocence Network, a collective of independently-run innocence organizations across the United States and abroad. We share information through an electronic network and email lists, and support one another’s efforts to exonerate the innocent and pursue policy changes to prevent wrongful convictions in a variety of ways. NCIP staff serves on the Executive Board of the Innocence Network, and we assist in the planning of and participation in national and regional conferences, symposia, and public education efforts.

How are law students involved in your work?

NCIP runs a two-semester clinical program in which students enroll and receive credit for working with NCIP staff attorneys on cases and policy issues. NCIP’s clinical program is one of the top programs in the nation. More than 700 Santa Clara Law students have graduated from NCIP since 2001. NCIP’s clinical students master key lawyering skills while also developing a clear sense of their ethical obligations as future lawyers. To learn more about the NCIP law clinic, click here.

How are you funded?

NCIP is funded by more than 500 individual, foundation, government and corporate funders each year. Gifts and grants range in size from $5 to more than $500,000. NCIPs funding comes from a variety of sources but roughly breaks down into the following categories: individual contributions 40%; government grants 30%; SCU Law 18%; private foundations 10%; endowment interest 2%. We also receive more than $1 million in in-kind pro bono services from lawyers, investigators and other service providers. To see NCIP’s latest financial report click here. To donate to NCIP, click here.

Do you work on issues other than individual cases?

NCIP’s core mission is to create a fair, effective and compassionate criminal justice system and to exonerate the innocent. As such, in addition to our case work, we seek to advance policy issues that are relevant to preventing wrongful convictions, supporting exonerees, and reforming the criminal justice as a whole. This take various forms: from state and federal legislative efforts, to public education symposia, to trainings we conduct for police departments, public defender offices, and other entities. You can help! To join our mailing list and be kept up to date on how you can support our policy efforts, click here.

Why are there wrongful convictions? What are the key causes?

The most common causes that contribute to wrongful convictions include eyewitness error, false testimony (by snitches or other witnesses), false confessions, faulty forensics or reliance upon “junk science,” official misconduct, and ineffective representation by defense attorneys.

Underlying nearly all wrongful convictions is some form of cognitive bias that distracts the investigators, prosecutors and/or defense attorneys from seeing real flaws in the evidence. Sometimes people are convinced that a particular person committed the crime or that evidence points in a particular direction. When there are conflicting facts or evidence which potentially shows a different story, sometimes investigators or attorneys don’t allow themselves (consciously or unconsciously) to revise their assumptions which may lead to a different person being identified as the true perpetrator. For example, many eyewitness misidentifications result from police using outdated identification practices that can unintentionally lead a witness to select the person the police already suspect of committing the crime. When the police’s suspect is NOT the actual perpetrator, however, such unintentional influence can result in an innocent person getting convicted.

Our educational efforts are focused on raising awareness of the ways in which cognitive bias can influence witness identifications, how witnesses or suspects are questioned, and even the results of forensic testing. We rely upon current scientific research into best practices in law enforcement procedures and forensics, in our efforts to educate law students, law enforcement professionals, and the public.

How many people has NCIP exonerated?  How long did they spend in prison?

October 16, 2017, NCIP has attained justice for 20 people who, collectively, spent over 256 years in prison, wrongfully convicted.

How long does it take to exonerate someone? Why does it take so long?

Every case is different and the time it takes to exonerate a client depends upon the nature of the evidence, the age of the case, the difficulty in locating relevant documents, physical evidence, and/or witnesses.  Our exonerations have taken from just over a year to nearly 12 years.

Is DNA evidence the only way to exonerate someone?

No. We rely upon all forms of investigation, including witness interviews, to investigate innocence claims. Only a small number of cases have DNA evidence which can be tested. However, there may be other forensic evidence that is questionable, such as the use of “bite mark” or “hair comparison” evidence. NCIP relies upon experts in a variety of scientific and medical disciplines to help interpret the evidence used at trial and to determine whether new evidence can be found that demonstrates that the wrong person was convicted or that the crime did not happen in the way it was presented at the time of trial.

How much does it cost to exonerate someone?

The costs of each case vary but it is expensive. In addition to the core costs of lawyers, most cases involve paid investigators who, while discounting their rates to work with NCIP, spend countless hours tracking down witnesses and finding evidence. In addition, paid experts are often critical to our cases. Experts help to analyze evidence and may testify at trial. Their fees are often several hundred dollars per hour. Where DNA is available for testing, tests can cost between $1500 – $5000 each. In addition, there are many smaller costs which add up quickly including copying fees for thousands of pages of transcripts or court records. As our cases are drawn from counties throughout Northern and Central California, travel costs are also significant. As expensive as our cases are, they are still extremely cost effective. To make a donation to offset the costs of exonerating an innocent person, click here. To read more about the impact of your donation, click here.

What happens to a person when they are exonerated and are released from prison?

At this point, the State of California provides no specific services to exonerees, and the limited services offered to parolees are not extended to the innocent, whose convictions have been vacated, rather than fully served. Depending on the length of incarceration, exonerees need a variety of services. They need to locate housing and transportation. They often have urgent medical and dental needs. They need employment or job training, counseling, and emotional support.

Do exonerees get compensation?

By law, California exonerees can apply for compensation from the State for the time that they spent wrongfully incarcerated. In most cases, this requires an application (entirely separate from the legal case that resulted in a court order vacating the conviction), supported by proof that the person is actually innocent. State compensation is limited to $140 per day wrongfully incarcerated (up from $100 per day thanks to NCIP-sponsored legislation adopted in 2015.) Compensation is not, however, automatic and historically, a fairly arbitrary administrative procedure resulted in many exonerees being denied compensation, even when the prosecutors in their cases conceded innocence. Recent legislative reform, supported by NCIP policy efforts, is intended to prevent such unfair outcomes in the future.

How many innocent people are in prison?

No one knows how many innocent people are in prison. Since 1989, however, more than 200 wrongful convictions have been vacated in California. The costs to the state of wrongful convictions have been estimated at more than $129 million, including the costs of incarceration and compensation, and not including the cost of the post-conviction litigation.

How can I get involved?

There are many ways to get involved with NCIP. Support us, join our mailing list, partner with us.

How can I donate to NCIP?

NCIP relies on individual donations. Your gift of any size is deeply appreciated. To donate, click here.